Ep. 49: Michael Gentile | Gold, Mining & De-Dollarization

Michael Gentile has 90 percent of his personal net worth in 35 junior mining companies. He is the largest shareholder in most of them. He has been writing checks since 2018, when the institutional mining world had gone dark, and he plans to hold for 5 to 10 more years. In this episode of Y’all Street, Gentile sits down with Tarek Saab to walk through the macro thesis behind that bet: what rising U.S. debt and de-dollarization signal for gold, why junior mining stocks are trading at the same per-ounce valuations they held in 2011 despite gold going from $1,900 to $4,500, and what it actually looks like to invest at the bottom of a commodity cycle when the only other check writers in the room are a handful of Canadians.

Key Takeaways

Junior Mining Stocks Are Dramatically Undervalued at $4,500 Gold:

In 2011 and 2012, when gold was $1,900 an ounce, the average pre-production resource company in Gentile’s sector traded at $50 to $150 per ounce in the ground. Today, with gold at $4,500 an ounce, those same companies still trade at $30 to $150 per ounce in the ground. The best producers’ profit margins have expanded from roughly $500 per ounce in 2011 to roughly $2,500 per ounce today: five times the margin, the same ounce valuation. The explanation, Gentile argues, is institutional: generalist capital has not arrived yet. It is parked in AI and semiconductor stocks, waiting for a story that sticks. When it rotates, the valuation gap in junior mining closes fast.

Gold Doesn’t Go Up. Paper Currencies Go Down:

Gentile reframes the standard question about the gold price. The correct question, he says, is not what gold will do but how much money governments will have to print to float interest on their debt. The United States carries approximately $40 trillion in total debt. At 5 percent average interest rate, that is $2 trillion per year in interest expense. Federal revenue was approximately $5.2 trillion last year. When 40 percent of your annual revenue goes to debt service, the only structural path forward is currency debasement. Gold measures that debasement. When investors say gold is going up, what is actually happening is that the dollar is going down.

The Russian FX Reserve Seizure Was the De-Dollarization Catalyst:

When the United States froze Russian foreign exchange reserves following the 2022 invasion of Ukraine, it sent a signal to every sovereign wealth manager holding the majority of reserves in U.S. dollars: those reserves are not safe if geopolitical tensions escalate. Central bank gold as a percentage of global FX reserves went from approximately 6 percent at that time to approximately 25 percent today. China set a record by purchasing 20 tons of gold in one month. Countries that had already been running the debasement math now had a second reason to act. That trend, Gentile argues, will not reverse because the memories are too long and the institutional preference for hard assets too well established.

Emotional Intelligence Beats High IQ in a Down Market:

When Warren Buffett was asked what it takes to be a good investor, he said emotional intelligence. He would take someone with 130 IQ who controls their emotions over someone with 180 IQ who cannot. Gentile heard this in person on a university class trip to Omaha, where Buffett answered questions over dinner for three hours. He has applied it through every down cycle since: when positions are falling 50 to 80 percent and the market is screaming sell, the discipline to ask “what fundamentally changed” rather than react to price action is what separates investors who stay through a cycle from investors who exit at the bottom.

The VC Framework Applied to Junior Mining:

Gentile structures every investment like a venture capital fund. Initial check: 1 percent of total capital. Target ownership at entry: 5 to 20 percent of the company. Required return on the first check: 20 to 50 times. If the company executes, he adds through up to five additional financing rounds, building to as much as 5 percent of his total book. If the company fails to execute, he stops writing checks. Maximum loss on a single mistake: the original 1 percent. He reviews approximately 500 opportunities per year and does five to seven investments. One Amazon or one Facebook pays for the whole fund. The same math applies to his junior mining book.

Notable Quotes

“Gold doesn’t go up. Paper currencies go down. Gold is just a measurement of how much excess money printing we have to engineer to keep the country from going bankrupt.” — Michael Gentile

“When your stocks are down 50%, the market’s yelling at you to sell. One of my best attributes is the calm. I try to let the fundamentals dictate my decisions.” — Michael Gentile

“I love bear markets. If you’re a commodity investor and you’re bullish, you should love bear markets. It gives you more time to get more quality investments in your book before the inevitable rebound happens.” — Michael Gentile

“Most investors are great at buying and terrible at selling because they get excited about buying but they don’t have an exit plan.” — Michael Gentile

Mentioned Resources

• Organizations: Formula Growth (Montreal institutional equities), Bank of Montreal Mining Conference
• People: Warren Buffett (met in Omaha), Charles Hager (Formula Growth partner), Eric Sprott (referenced as fellow check writer during the bear market period)
• Markets and Instruments: Gold, silver, copper, platinum, palladium; Pittman Robertson Act; BRICS central bank reserve data
• Newsletter: saturdaymorningmining.com
• Events: Gentile Mining Forum, London (October 19); Gentile Icebreaker, Vancouver (VRIC show)
• Portfolio: goldsignal.ai/portfolios/michael-gentile

This material must be preceded or accompanied by a prospectus. Please read the prospectus carefully before investing.
YSAU | YSAG
The Fund is not an investment company registered under the Investment Company Act of 1940 and is not subject to the same regulations thereunder.